Top 10 Personal Injury Lawyer In Columbus
By Sheila Morgan | Published: 2025-06-15 | Category: Personal Injury Lawyer
About Personal Injury Lawyer In Columbus
Personal injury lawyers represent individuals who have been physically or psychologically harmed due to the negligence or wrongdoing of another person, company, or entity. They help clients secure compensation for medical expenses, lost wages, pain and suffering, and other damages.
How We Evaluated
Firms were evaluated based on their local presence, years of experience, client testimonials, breadth of personal injury case specialization, and reported track record of success. Publicly available information and online reviews were primary sources for this assessment.
Rating Criteria
- → Experience & Reputation
- → Client Satisfaction
- → Case Specialization
- → Accessibility & Communication
- → Reported Success
The Best Personal Injury Lawyer In Columbus
Agee Clymer Mitchell & Portman
Visit Website →A prominent Ohio law firm specializing in workers' compensation, social security disability, and personal injury law, serving clients in Columbus and statewide.
Target Audience
Injured workers, Individuals seeking disability benefits, Personal injury victims
Service Offerings
Personal Injury
Representation for auto accidents, premises liability, and other negligence claims.
- Free consultations
- Contingency fee basis
Workers' Compensation
Comprehensive assistance with Ohio BWC claims.
- From initial filing through all appeal levels
Social Security Disability
Helping clients secure SSDI and SSI benefits.
- Experienced in administrative hearings
Scorecard (Overall: 4.3 / 5.0)
Pricing Model
Contingency Fee
No attorney fees unless they win your case.
Pros
- + Strong focus on claimant rights in injury and disability
- + Multiple office locations for convenience
- + Experienced team
Cons
- - Broader focus than a pure PI boutique firm
- - May handle high volume of cases
Verdict
"A well-regarded firm for individuals needing help with personal injury, workers' comp, or social security disability claims."
Larrimer & Larrimer, LLC
Visit Website →An esteemed Ohio law firm primarily focused on workers' compensation and social security disability, also handling related personal injury cases.
Target Audience
Injured workers, Individuals with disabilities, Victims of third-party negligence at work
Service Offerings
Workers' Compensation
Deep expertise in Ohio BWC claims and appeals.
- Representing injured employees across Ohio
Personal Injury (often related to work)
Handling third-party personal injury claims arising from workplace accidents.
- Cases against negligent non-employer parties
Social Security Disability
Assisting clients in obtaining SSDI and SSI benefits.
- Applications and appeals
Scorecard (Overall: 4.3 / 5.0)
Pricing Model
Contingency Fee
No fee unless benefits or compensation are recovered.
Pros
- + Exceptional reputation in workers' compensation
- + Very long history and experience
- + Dedicated to injured and disabled individuals
Cons
- - Primary focus is not general personal injury
- - Best suited for PI cases linked to work injuries
Verdict
"A top choice for work-related injuries and disability claims, with strong PI capabilities for associated third-party actions."
User Reviews
Add Your Review
Loading reviews...
Tyack Law Firm Co., L.P.A.
Visit Website →A long-standing Columbus law firm with a diverse practice that includes personal injury, criminal defense, and family law.
Target Audience
Individuals needing PI representation, Clients who may need other legal services
Service Offerings
Personal Injury Claims
Representation for injuries from auto accidents, falls, and other negligent acts.
- Experienced trial attorneys
Civil Litigation
Broader civil dispute resolution including injury claims.
- Negotiation, mediation, and trial
Scorecard (Overall: 4.1 / 5.0)
Pricing Model
Contingency Fee
Typically works on contingency for personal injury cases.
Pros
- + Very established firm with decades of history in Columbus
- + Experienced litigators
- + Broad legal knowledge
Cons
- - Personal injury is not their sole focus
- - May not have the same depth in PI as specialized firms
Verdict
"A historic Columbus firm offering reliable personal injury representation as part of a wider array of legal services."
User Reviews
Add Your Review
Loading reviews...
Gallagher, Gams, Tallan, Barnes & Littrell, L.L.P. (GBH Law)
Visit Website →A multi-practice law firm with a dedicated personal injury department, offering experienced representation in Columbus.
Target Audience
Individuals seeking established firm for PI, Clients needing diverse legal expertise
Service Offerings
Personal Injury & Wrongful Death
Comprehensive services for accident victims and their families.
- Vehicle accidents
- Premises liability
- Product liability
Insurance Disputes
Handling bad faith insurance claims related to personal injury.
- Unfair claim denials
- Delayed payments
Scorecard (Overall: 4.1 / 5.0)
Pricing Model
Contingency Fee
Fees are contingent upon securing a recovery for the client.
Pros
- + Established firm with a broad range of legal services
- + Experienced litigation team
- + Professional office environment
Cons
- - Personal injury is one of several practice areas, not sole focus
- - May feel less specialized than boutique PI firms
Verdict
"A reputable full-service firm for clients who may appreciate a broader legal backing for their personal injury case."
User Reviews
Add Your Review
Loading reviews...
Plymale & Dingus, LLC
Visit Website →Columbus law firm focusing on personal injury, workers' compensation, and medical malpractice cases, with a commitment to client advocacy.
Target Audience
Injured workers, Victims of negligence, Medical malpractice victims
Service Offerings
Personal Injury
Representation for various injuries including auto accidents, slip and falls.
- Negotiation and litigation expertise
Workers' Compensation
Assisting injured workers navigate the Ohio BWC system.
- Claim filing
- Appeals
- Lump sum settlements
Medical Malpractice
Advocating for patients harmed by medical errors.
- Thorough case evaluation
- Expert witness coordination
Scorecard (Overall: 4.3 / 5.0)
Pricing Model
Contingency Fee
No upfront fees; payment only upon successful recovery.
Pros
- + Dual focus on personal injury and workers' comp beneficial for workplace injuries
- + Experienced local attorneys
- + Free case evaluations
Cons
- - Website could offer more detailed case result information
Verdict
"A strong option for those with personal injury claims, especially if a workers' compensation aspect is involved."
User Reviews
Add Your Review
Loading reviews...
Scott Elliot Smith, LPA
Visit Website →A Columbus-based personal injury law firm with over 30 years of experience, dedicated to representing injured individuals and their families.
Target Audience
Individuals injured in accidents, Families seeking justice for loved ones
Service Offerings
Auto Accidents
Handling all types of motor vehicle collisions, including cars, trucks, and motorcycles.
- Uninsured/underinsured motorist claims
- Hit and run accidents
Premises Liability
Representing clients injured due to unsafe property conditions.
- Slip/trip and fall
- Inadequate security
- Building code violations
Wrongful Death
Providing compassionate legal support for families grieving a loss due to negligence.
- Pursuing compensation for economic and non-economic damages
Scorecard (Overall: 4.4 / 5.0)
Pricing Model
Contingency Fee
You pay nothing unless we win your case.
Pros
- + Personalized attention from an experienced attorney
- + Focus on client communication
- + Local Columbus firm
Cons
- - Smaller firm, may have fewer resources than larger competitors for massive cases
Verdict
"A solid choice for those seeking dedicated, personal service from an experienced Columbus injury lawyer."
User Reviews
Add Your Review
Loading reviews...
The Donahey Law Firm
Visit Website →One of Ohio's oldest personal injury firms, providing experienced legal representation to Columbus residents for over 50 years.
Target Audience
Victims of medical malpractice, Construction accident victims, Car accident victims
Service Offerings
Medical Malpractice
Significant experience in handling complex medical negligence cases.
- Birth injuries
- Surgical errors
- Failure to diagnose
Workplace Injuries
Representation for injuries sustained on the job, including third-party claims.
- Construction accidents
- Factory accidents
Product Liability
Holding manufacturers accountable for defective products that cause harm.
- Design defects
- Manufacturing flaws
- Failure to warn
Scorecard (Overall: 4.5 / 5.0)
Pricing Model
Contingency Fee
No fees are charged unless a settlement or verdict is obtained.
Pros
- + Extensive history and deep experience
- + Strong reputation in medical malpractice
- + Commitment to client rights
Cons
- - Older firm, communication style may be more traditional
Verdict
"A highly reputable and experienced firm, particularly strong in medical malpractice and complex injury cases."
User Reviews
Add Your Review
Loading reviews...
Slater & Zurz LLP
Visit Website →A statewide Ohio law firm with a strong personal injury practice, serving Columbus residents with decades of experience.
Target Audience
General personal injury claimants, Motor vehicle accident victims
Service Offerings
Personal Injury Litigation
Comprehensive representation for a variety of injury types.
- From initial consultation to trial if necessary
Motorcycle Accidents
Advocacy for injured motorcyclists facing unique challenges.
- Addressing bias against riders
- Accident reconstruction
Dog Bites
Helping victims of dog attacks recover damages.
- Strict liability claims
- Scarring and emotional distress compensation
Scorecard (Overall: 4.4 / 5.0)
Pricing Model
Contingency Fee
No attorney fees unless compensation is recovered.
Pros
- + Long-standing firm with a broad reach
- + Experienced trial lawyers
- + Free initial consultations
Cons
- - As a larger firm, client experience can vary
- - Website could be more modern
Verdict
"A reliable firm with a long history in Ohio, suitable for a wide range of personal injury claims."
User Reviews
Add Your Review
Loading reviews...
The Fitch Law Firm LLC
Visit Website →A dedicated personal injury firm in Columbus with over 30 years of experience, focusing on serious injury and wrongful death cases.
Target Audience
Victims of serious accidents, Individuals with catastrophic injuries
Service Offerings
Serious Injury Claims
Handling complex cases involving brain injuries, spinal cord injuries, and amputations.
- Life care planning
- Maximizing compensation for long-term needs
Truck Accidents
Specialized representation for complex commercial truck accident cases.
- Investigating FMSCA violations
- Dealing with multiple liable parties
Premises Liability
Claims for injuries sustained on someone else's property due to unsafe conditions.
- Slip and fall
- Negligent security
Scorecard (Overall: 4.5 / 5.0)
Pricing Model
Contingency Fee
Clients pay no fees unless a recovery is made.
Pros
- + Highly experienced lead attorney
- + Focus on significant injury cases
- + Positive client testimonials
Cons
- - May be selective in case acceptance due to focus on severe injuries
Verdict
"Excellent for complex and serious injury cases, offering experienced and compassionate legal support."
User Reviews
Add Your Review
Loading reviews...
View Top Ranked Provider
Watch a short ad to unlock the details for the #1 ranked provider.
Kisling, Nestico & Redick
Visit Website →A well-known Ohio personal injury law firm with a significant presence in Columbus, handling a wide range of accident and injury cases.
Target Audience
Accident victims, Injured individuals, Families seeking wrongful death claims
Service Offerings
Car Accidents
Representation for victims of car, truck, and motorcycle accidents.
- Negotiating with insurance companies
- Litigation for fair compensation
Medical Malpractice
Cases involving negligence by healthcare professionals.
- Birth injuries
- Surgical errors
- Misdiagnosis
Wrongful Death
Assisting families who have lost a loved one due to negligence.
- Securing compensation for loss of income and companionship
Scorecard (Overall: 4.6 / 5.0)
Pricing Model
Contingency Fee
No fee unless we win your case.
Pros
- + Large firm with extensive resources
- + Strong brand recognition in Ohio
- + Numerous office locations
Cons
- - May have a higher volume of cases, potentially impacting personal attention for some
- - Primarily focused on Ohio
Verdict
"A leading choice for personal injury representation in Columbus, known for aggressive advocacy and significant resources."
User Reviews
Add Your Review
Loading reviews...
Final Recommendation
Columbus offers a range of highly qualified personal injury lawyers, from large, well-resourced firms to smaller practices providing personalized attention. Many firms operate on a contingency fee basis, ensuring access to justice for injured individuals. Key considerations when choosing a lawyer include their specific experience with your case type, track record, and communication style.
User Reviews
Add Your Review
Loading reviews...
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your thoughts!